**** BEGIN LOGGING AT Fri Feb 7 23:36:11 2003 Feb 07 23:36:11 --> You are now talking on #TheTradeGuild Feb 07 23:36:11 --- Topic for #TheTradeGuild is Trade Guilding Meeting will take place at 7 pm EST, Friday, Feb 7th Feb 07 23:36:11 --- Topic for #TheTradeGuild set by Hirokache at Thu Feb 6 18:40:37 Feb 07 23:36:24 hi Feb 07 23:36:36 mind if I watch? Feb 07 23:37:11 I'm not too likely to become a trader, but the traders' guild thread is absolutely fascinating Feb 07 23:37:33 and you might want some potential customers to comment on some things ;) Feb 07 23:41:53 and someone was going to post the logs anyway ;) Feb 07 23:48:10 --> Earwin (earwin@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #TheTradeGuild Feb 07 23:48:25 Hello Feb 07 23:49:26 hi Feb 07 23:53:15 --> Ahmeni (Setau@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 07 23:53:58 --> DWing010[NRP] (DWing010_N@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 07 23:54:25 --> Hellinar (tdtravel@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 07 23:54:31 --- Hirokache_Away is now known as Hirokache Feb 07 23:54:40 Now to just figure out logging on this danged client. Feb 07 23:54:55 Ah, this looks like the right place Feb 07 23:55:00 * FaceAnkh|afk is logging Feb 07 23:55:08 I can post logs later if you like Feb 07 23:55:18 Okay, I think I'm logging now. Feb 07 23:55:31 ? Feb 07 23:55:39 Though I'm going to restart to be sure Feb 07 23:55:41 <-- Ahmeni has quit (Quit: fractal 1.0.9b60 - ONLINE: Computerese for "The damn board finally answered!" - http://fractalscript.com) Feb 07 23:55:49 --> Ahmeni (Setau@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 07 23:55:59 test Feb 07 23:56:05 I am in and out of the kitchen but will follow along :) Feb 07 23:56:05 Woo. Feb 07 23:56:19 Howdy folks Feb 07 23:56:24 Hi Feb 07 23:56:25 Heya Hiro Feb 07 23:56:36 Hi Hiro Feb 07 23:57:04 Do one or two people want to volunteer as back up secretaries and take a log of the meeting? Feb 07 23:57:11 Hi Feb 07 23:57:14 I'll log and edit. Feb 07 23:57:25 Thanks. Feb 07 23:57:36 Hi to the early crowd! Feb 07 23:57:47 I'll keep an eye on ATITD irc and direct people here Feb 07 23:57:49 Allo Hellinar Feb 07 23:57:56 Who was living next to me the entire time! ;) Feb 07 23:58:34 Any signs of Lun-Ur? Feb 07 23:58:52 Thanks Earwin ... haven't figured out the quick wy to switch between the channels I'm in yet here Feb 07 23:59:01 --> Lun-Ur[Trader] (Lun-Ur@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #THETRADEGUILD Feb 07 23:59:05 Yep Feb 07 23:59:09 ;p Feb 07 23:59:12 Hi Feb 07 23:59:20 Hi Lun-Ur[Trader] Feb 07 23:59:21 Hello Lun Feb 07 23:59:33 * DWing010[NRP] is writing Java, but is here Feb 07 23:59:36 Speak of the devil.. Feb 07 23:59:45 --> chephren|afk (nycgeoff@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #TheTradeGuild Feb 07 23:59:48 hi all Feb 07 23:59:54 I'm the devil? Feb 07 23:59:55 allo Chephren Feb 07 23:59:59 --- chephren|afk is now known as Chephren Feb 08 00:00:00 Evening chephren Feb 08 00:00:11 * Hellinar wishes he could talk and write Java at the same time Feb 08 00:00:40 It is a power that comes at great cost. Feb 08 00:01:01 hehe, how many more bugs do you end up with while multitasking like that? Feb 08 00:01:19 --> obiwan (homegrown@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:01:19 Oh, the clock tower is ringing here Feb 08 00:01:27 Must be time to start :) Feb 08 00:01:29 --> Sprocket (anon42@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #TheTradeGuild Feb 08 00:01:33 --> otter (dianascan@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:01:37 Hi Sprocket, otter Feb 08 00:01:42 hi Feb 08 00:02:16 hi guys Feb 08 00:02:22 just here to say hi since I wont be playing rally Feb 08 00:02:53 * otter thinks of blackmarket warping.... Feb 08 00:02:57 Feel free to join the discussion if you'd like Feb 08 00:02:57 Going into tonight I think the only thing we have set in stone is one policy: A Trader's Guild will not restrict members to one guild only. It seems everything else still needs to be hashed out. Feb 08 00:02:57 naaaaa Feb 08 00:03:00 rally or really? Feb 08 00:03:05 Is it ok to join the meeting even if I dont plan to join the trade guild? (at least not as primary guild) Feb 08 00:03:08 <-- Hellinar has quit (Read error: Connection reset by peer) Feb 08 00:03:17 --> Dragynne (dragynne@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #TheTradeGuild Feb 08 00:03:22 yes, please do Sprocket :) Feb 08 00:03:28 more the merrier Feb 08 00:03:30 Nope go away Sprocket :) Feb 08 00:03:34 <-- Dragynne (dragynne@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has left #TheTradeGuild Feb 08 00:03:39 =] Feb 08 00:03:39 <-- otter (dianascan@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has left #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:03:50 Isn' Feb 08 00:03:53 Isn Feb 08 00:03:56 Grrrrr Feb 08 00:04:15 Isn't the number one issue for a trader and guild TRUST? Feb 08 00:04:29 Definately Feb 08 00:04:29 The first step I think is to work out something of a game plan for the first week Feb 08 00:04:29 IF we get a bad apple we are DOA Feb 08 00:04:40 either that or ruthless control of the means of production :) Feb 08 00:04:54 --> Hellinar (tdtravel@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:05:12 Quite true, and how to deal with that is another topic in need of addressing, we can start with that instead :) Feb 08 00:05:22 Actually supply Chep, like emron Feb 08 00:05:47 How would you suggest avoiding such bad apples Earwin? Feb 08 00:06:22 --> Magon[NRP] (magon@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:06:44 needs to be an established trader? Feb 08 00:06:45 I don't know Hiro and it does worry me. What is the status on chest access restrictions? Are there guild chest that memeber can put things in but only eldars can remove? Feb 08 00:07:14 Not necesarrily an established trader. Feb 08 00:07:28 what about a deposit?? if reports of bad apples are found then that deposit can cover damages Feb 08 00:07:29 That I'm not sure of ... does anyone else know? Feb 08 00:07:55 Maybe the guild should start as a communication device, and spin off more close knit guilds as people get to trust each other Feb 08 00:07:55 That works more as an insurance policy. That would be cool. Feb 08 00:07:59 The only chest restrictions are the guild chest restrictions Feb 08 00:08:14 No eldars chest? Feb 08 00:08:16 Yes, Hellinar is probably correct Feb 08 00:08:36 A deposit might work, but it would be a bit of a pain. Who collects it? Where do we keep it? If there number of traders i small enough its not a problem, but if there are a lot of people that becomes hard to track Feb 08 00:08:37 Well, we can make a big leap by establishing a front of well respected citizens. Feb 08 00:08:39 Start out as a loose federation of individual traders Feb 08 00:09:00 (or smaller trade guilds) Feb 08 00:09:08 --- Lun-Ur[Trader] is now known as Lun-Ur Feb 08 00:09:18 Yes, I agree with Hellinar and Lun-Ur, and I would go further and say stick to regional trading guilds first Feb 08 00:09:27 Perhaps a federation, that also offers services for a low prize to its members (such as help with getting waypoints) Feb 08 00:09:27 We could start small sub guilds that trust each other with some interconnection Feb 08 00:09:37 It would be nice to have the Trader chat channel as soon as possible Feb 08 00:09:38 Sub guilds is a lot of work to build up from. Feb 08 00:09:49 we can do both, right? Feb 08 00:09:53 and just consolidate more power Feb 08 00:10:03 in the meta-trade guild as the game progresses... Feb 08 00:10:09 If we want to get our trader channel up, odds are we're going to have to help the region that we establish in get bootstrapped. Feb 08 00:10:16 Quick poll.... right now, who would trust as a guild-mate? ... type your answer Feb 08 00:10:37 in here? Sprocket Feb 08 00:10:46 Hellinar. Feb 08 00:10:46 Yes, in here Feb 08 00:10:49 not neccesarily Ahmeni, you just need bricks and boards Feb 08 00:10:58 And canvas. Feb 08 00:11:02 somebody will get LPM Feb 08 00:11:05 There are quite a few here I would trust. Feb 08 00:11:07 I would trust everybody, but I'm a trusting role=playing soul, as arule Feb 08 00:11:14 On personal level: Hiro - based on reputation: most people Feb 08 00:11:16 But I don't think that is the best way to start Feb 08 00:11:18 I would probably trust more than that, but he's the only one I've met in game yet :) Feb 08 00:11:34 I would in DW and Ahmeni. Feb 08 00:11:35 oh.. if you can select more than one I'd trust most in this room ;) Feb 08 00:11:38 I havn't met many of you in the game Feb 08 00:11:41 --> Bellah[SOT] (bellah@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:11:45 And FA..:P Feb 08 00:11:53 What we need to establish these webs of trust in communities. Feb 08 00:12:10 I would set up my own guild, and let people in as initiates, then they can deposit stuff in chests for me Feb 08 00:12:16 I tend to trust most of the people are argue with on the ATITD boards :D Feb 08 00:12:28 i trust most until i have a reason not to Feb 08 00:12:51 If they do the same, I can have a small network of people I regularly trade with, later, we could merge guilds and do more Feb 08 00:13:01 I'm fairly trusting too... but we're talking about establishing what needs to be the MOST TRUSTED Guild in the game Feb 08 00:13:35 and we will start with a few and grow... Feb 08 00:13:37 Yup transfering 20 saphires to a guild chest could be pretty nerve wracking Feb 08 00:13:38 is it easy to remove people from a guild? I soloed in Beta3, so I have no idea Feb 08 00:13:46 Well, I think the major trust in the game comes from things in where both players make a small sacrifice so that both may prosper Feb 08 00:13:48 Would anyone here want to just be an Associate to the guild instead a Member or Elder? Feb 08 00:13:48 yes, any elder can do so Feb 08 00:14:15 what's the worst thing a "bad apple" could do? Feb 08 00:14:25 steal from a buyer instead of trade? Feb 08 00:14:28 Steal what we are helping to move. Feb 08 00:14:30 Make people stop trading with the guild members Feb 08 00:14:37 not complete a trade? steal from guild chests Feb 08 00:14:38 That there is the worst thing that can happen. Feb 08 00:14:46 I would have no problem with that myself as a start. I would have no probelm having to prove myself in game Feb 08 00:14:50 Once something like that happens, the trust is shattered. Feb 08 00:14:50 But you'll never know who griefed you. Thats why the trust and good-old friend needed... Feb 08 00:14:50 I am focussing on mentoring at first, so Initiate would be fine with me. I am just looking to keep track initially Feb 08 00:15:10 I'm not clear on the distinction between Assoc/Member/Elder Feb 08 00:15:16 who is mentoring at the start of game? Feb 08 00:15:18 I am going to be running all over Eqypt to start :D Feb 08 00:15:23 AFK one sorry Feb 08 00:15:28 obviously, as a relatively new player, I wouldn't presume to be an elder Feb 08 00:15:33 Important so we know how long we have to make the hall Feb 08 00:15:44 Elder has all the power. The other two levels can have chests which lower levels can't Take or Put Feb 08 00:15:53 --- You are now known as FaceAnkh Feb 08 00:16:13 Try this... Where is everyone planning on starting? Feb 08 00:16:15 7L Feb 08 00:16:18 VoK Feb 08 00:16:18 RP Feb 08 00:16:24 Hellinar's Retreat Feb 08 00:16:27 Undecided. Feb 08 00:16:27 VoK most likely, but not definite yet Feb 08 00:16:28 well OE, but going to RP Feb 08 00:16:30 undecided Feb 08 00:17:08 I don't plan on having any personal camp though ... I will be following my guild. Feb 08 00:17:18 So one plan is to be a trader in that region for a while and all meet in RP on Sunday. Feb 08 00:17:28 RP Feb 08 00:17:40 I'm not planning on building any buildings at all in Live, except to help build the Trader guild Feb 08 00:17:43 --> Ethros[NRP] (Ethros@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:17:46 NRP rocks! Feb 08 00:17:54 will there be more than one guild hall located across egytp or is that possible Feb 08 00:18:08 Not currently, because the chat channel is unique per Guild Hall Feb 08 00:18:15 Other regions can just have chests and tents Feb 08 00:18:16 k Feb 08 00:18:18 I'm just planning on a wood plane and a bunch of small chests :) Feb 08 00:18:22 And marketplaces, etc. Feb 08 00:18:48 joining the guild could be a hastle Feb 08 00:18:48 No one wants to live in Sinai? Feb 08 00:18:50 so, how early do we want the chat channel? Feb 08 00:18:59 i like sinia Feb 08 00:19:14 Well, the chat channel isn't crippling without, as we still have IRC, but it should be on the list somewhat early. Feb 08 00:19:22 just don't like getting there or leaving with out using waypoint Feb 08 00:19:24 I agree with Ahmeni Feb 08 00:19:26 I suggest the chat channel is needed once everyone has Nav +1 to get back to their home region Feb 08 00:19:41 so, Sunday night Feb 08 00:19:59 or early in the week Feb 08 00:20:05 30 hours should be enough to get 1000 thorns, yes? Feb 08 00:20:09 assuming we can all find thorn bushes :) Feb 08 00:20:27 Sunday night should work for me, though I could be late running down there as I have to work all day Feb 08 00:20:30 1000 thorns isn't very hard, no Feb 08 00:20:31 trying to keep up with irc and chat channels gets to be to much Feb 08 00:20:33 that accounts if people want to mentor also Feb 08 00:20:41 Ya you can do the thorn way point in about 2 hours Feb 08 00:20:49 Well, I expect i will have to, my schedule does change week to week, so I'll know then Feb 08 00:20:49 and NRP will have someone with LPM in that area Feb 08 00:21:05 Well, we all don't need to show up at once if everyone who shows up chips in a few extra bricks to build the Guild Hall. Feb 08 00:21:23 Who is planning to settle where? I will most likely end up a little north of RP Feb 08 00:21:29 ... poll ... where does everyone live on Earth? Feb 08 00:21:40 Put your time zone as well. Feb 08 00:21:40 EST Feb 08 00:21:46 NYC - EST Feb 08 00:21:46 PST - Bainbridge Island, WA Feb 08 00:21:46 Vancouver, BC - PST Feb 08 00:21:53 North Carolina, USA -- EST Feb 08 00:21:55 EST Feb 08 00:21:57 CST Feb 08 00:22:00 UK, GMT Feb 08 00:22:10 Woo UK! Feb 08 00:22:17 sorry its so late for you folks across the pond Feb 08 00:22:24 ... interesting ... all coasties except obiwan Feb 08 00:22:26 high concentration of western timezones Feb 08 00:22:37 Only 2 PST Feb 08 00:22:38 i live on third coast Feb 08 00:22:46 4 EST Feb 08 00:22:49 Texas? Feb 08 00:22:54 Houston Feb 08 00:23:04 EST Feb 08 00:23:20 So one more todo is to get more Europeans to help trade Feb 08 00:23:21 what about houston tx? Feb 08 00:23:26 im in houston tx Feb 08 00:23:32 and australians Feb 08 00:23:34 TST Texas standar Time Feb 08 00:23:36 I think I'll be doing a lot of am playing Feb 08 00:23:49 Its possible there are more who wish to ... this meeting isn't at a very friendly Euro time Feb 08 00:23:54 which is more of a european prime time, I would imagine Feb 08 00:24:06 i live in Houston Feb 08 00:24:15 where abouts obiwan? Feb 08 00:24:28 North outside Spring Feb 08 00:24:37 and u? Feb 08 00:24:38 this is logged and posted Feb 08 00:24:38 right? Feb 08 00:24:44 im just south of beltway 8 in friendwood myself Feb 08 00:24:44 Hirokache, you should get a Trader's forum set up on atitd.net. I think Tcrhin will do that. Feb 08 00:24:56 Yes, DWing Feb 08 00:25:16 I was going to ask what we thought up setting up a bit of a website Feb 08 00:25:26 I'm all for a website Feb 08 00:26:03 That way we could post info for the general public to go and look at as well as have our own forums Feb 08 00:26:19 good idea Feb 08 00:26:26 also, don't forget the regional trade forums.. Feb 08 00:26:29 --- Magon[NRP] is now known as Magon[NRP]|sleep Feb 08 00:26:42 What about using the All Egypt trade forum for now? Feb 08 00:26:44 Yes, advertising is good! Just make sure its on the links pages of atitd.com and atitd.net Feb 08 00:27:00 these seem, to me, to be farther down the to-do list, since we'll only be about 12-20 by live... Feb 08 00:27:06 I just meant a Guild forum for the members of the guild to debate Feb 08 00:27:15 out of the public eye :) Feb 08 00:27:34 I can setup that up tonight easily enough Feb 08 00:27:34 hehe, keep it public for a bit please - it's fascinating to read ;) Feb 08 00:27:42 The forum that is Feb 08 00:27:45 Yes, out of the public eye. Public stuff can stay in Guild Discussions, and Trade forums Feb 08 00:27:59 <-- Ethros[NRP] has quit (Quit: You know, you can probally blame my wife for this...) Feb 08 00:28:17 I have one more quick poll... Feb 08 00:28:19 A forum for ourselves would be as easy as throwing up phpBB (The board system ATITD.net is using), and that only takes about 15 minutes at most Feb 08 00:28:34 ... poll ... Name the Guild Feb 08 00:28:43 Join up Face, I doubt I will be a full time trader but I do like to travel so if some needs a delivery from sinai to seven lakes I'm your man :D Feb 08 00:28:58 I like The Trade Guild Feb 08 00:28:59 Egypt Trader's Guild -- ETG Feb 08 00:29:00 KISS Feb 08 00:29:01 Traders of Egypt? Feb 08 00:29:05 Free Traders of Egypt Feb 08 00:29:06 Traders of Egypt Feb 08 00:29:11 Hrm. Who was the Egyptian god of trade? Feb 08 00:29:14 The Trade Guild Feb 08 00:29:19 lol Feb 08 00:29:23 Free? You read too much into my non-profit post :-) Feb 08 00:29:32 hehe Feb 08 00:29:38 Earwin: one of the things that really interests me about this is the possibility of setting up a delivery service Feb 08 00:29:40 scratch the free part Feb 08 00:29:40 TRADE EQYPT or EQYPT TRADE Feb 08 00:30:12 Cool... the vote is split Feb 08 00:30:18 Earwin: it'd complement an organised traders guild very well.. Feb 08 00:30:26 My plan is to complet Studen of Body in the first three game days :D Feb 08 00:30:38 Sounds like a good poll for the boards then Feb 08 00:31:00 Yes, a poll sounds like a good way to settle the matter Feb 08 00:31:08 well, we have 9 days to debate it Feb 08 00:31:24 Guild Hall where? Feb 08 00:31:26 i will look up that egyptian trade god...lol Feb 08 00:31:38 Downtown RP Feb 08 00:32:02 I was thinking tentatively in that valley you mentioned Earwin ... Feb 08 00:32:03 RP Feb 08 00:32:05 A little slummy dont ya think? :D Feb 08 00:32:15 another poll for the boards Feb 08 00:32:17 Definitely RP though Feb 08 00:32:20 It's central to Egypt, unless the map has changed drastically Feb 08 00:32:25 seems like the right place to put it Feb 08 00:32:31 It needs to be central to save on waypoint juice Feb 08 00:32:35 I don't know enough about the area to know exactly where to put it over there Feb 08 00:32:44 if placed near NRP, you will have a major guild nearby Feb 08 00:32:52 That valley is probably where I will settle cause I can reach RP, Svok and OE in decent time Feb 08 00:32:59 and hopefully some public facilities ;) Feb 08 00:33:06 Is NRP a meta-Guild is a really big Guild? Feb 08 00:33:14 Yup Feb 08 00:33:18 big guild Feb 08 00:33:22 Too big for me, so I decided against joining. Feb 08 00:33:38 ~10 people from beta3 that know the game well Feb 08 00:33:39 Can you build right by the fountain in RP? Feb 08 00:33:40 I think there's support for an RP meta guild, but very little discussion on it :/ Feb 08 00:33:48 Ah, my mistake. So there's still just one meta-Guild, G7L Feb 08 00:33:58 500 feet from the fountain Feb 08 00:34:04 I believe another region was discussing one Feb 08 00:34:08 I might put out a more detailed proposal on the RP forums later in the week Feb 08 00:34:16 You can build near the fountain, yes. Feb 08 00:34:22 Does anyone know how drastic the map is being changed? Feb 08 00:34:28 Just as long as its a very short distance from the road. Feb 08 00:34:37 I think the map itself is staying the same Feb 08 00:34:43 The geography hasnt changed Feb 08 00:34:43 I think we'd have a better place down south Feb 08 00:34:49 But a lot of new schools Feb 08 00:34:59 In some ways, it might be better to be a little ways away from Downtown RP, its going to get crowded, and we may want to build more chests later Feb 08 00:35:10 I know the red lines are gone and the builder are very busy Feb 08 00:35:33 Anyone know the decay rules for live? Feb 08 00:35:33 I can document a few places in Southern RP I've discovered that would make good spots. Feb 08 00:35:33 I suggest you set up not too far from a UoW Feb 08 00:35:41 Strict Crowding system, Hellinar. Feb 08 00:35:44 ha - do we want to be downtown or be like WalMart :) Feb 08 00:35:45 Actually, the Traders can be in a spot unsuited for builders, like an area without water Feb 08 00:35:47 people will come by for seeds and cuttings too Feb 08 00:35:59 FaceAnkh, what do you think about some of those places southwest of the UoW? Feb 08 00:36:02 I think our guildhall should be downtown Feb 08 00:36:05 southeast, sorry. Feb 08 00:36:12 but we could have a "warehouse" someplace more remote Feb 08 00:36:15 if we need the space Feb 08 00:36:31 Thing is, RP got so crowded that it was a pain to run through. Feb 08 00:36:43 My Geforce4 cried at the bridge. Feb 08 00:36:44 crowding system should help Feb 08 00:36:45 but I think it's important to have a public presence Feb 08 00:36:47 Ahmeni: there are some really nice camp spots down that way, but as Lun-Ur says, it might be better to avoid grabbing a good spot if you're not going to use it Feb 08 00:36:59 Hellinar's Retreat is now full of schools and Uni's, so it will be a newbie area Feb 08 00:37:05 You're only going to waypoint in and waypoint out Feb 08 00:37:09 Yeah, the exact location will not matter a huge amount to us Feb 08 00:37:15 what about near the northern SoT Feb 08 00:37:21 Hrm. What about establishing a public presence with public facilities? Feb 08 00:37:24 in the desert Feb 08 00:37:43 where's your retreat, helinar? Feb 08 00:37:45 but we should make it convenient, no? Feb 08 00:37:50 I suggest leaving the public "parks" to the builders Feb 08 00:38:00 NE VoK, Cheprhren Feb 08 00:38:03 I think the public presence will be up to the individcuals in their various regions early on Feb 08 00:38:18 keep it near an important Egypt wide resource like a UoW - people will be happier to come to you then Feb 08 00:38:19 True. Feb 08 00:38:22 Face, are you joining NRP? Feb 08 00:38:29 for the bootstrap, yes Feb 08 00:38:36 And post-bootstrap? Feb 08 00:38:39 then I'll take some time to rebuild the public area Feb 08 00:38:41 I'm going to be writing up a petition to create a "Store" as soon as I'm done submitting the "Court of Egypt" petition. So don't think of the Guild Hall as the guild's storefront Feb 08 00:38:42 then I'll see :) Feb 08 00:38:50 By the time a lot of interregional trading is going on, and the trade guild camp becomes a necessary place to go to we shouldn't ned to worry about advertising as much Feb 08 00:39:01 <-- Earwin has quit (Ping timeout) Feb 08 00:39:03 We could have the guild hall near the fountain for Status and Advertising, and the wharehouse district that eveyone actually warps to out of town Feb 08 00:39:04 I'll sign that Lun Feb 08 00:39:18 I'm with Hellinar Feb 08 00:39:26 will these store fronts also be a type of bank? Feb 08 00:39:39 No, no, no, advertising is a constant problem. Every newbie needs to know about the Trader's Guild and how to place an order. Feb 08 00:39:44 Hellinar: have you decided where you're likely to hold the trade fairs? Feb 08 00:40:04 Place the hall near the SoA then? by the bridge Feb 08 00:40:19 In Beta3, the problem in late January was that I only new the players from December when my announcement was on atitd.net Feb 08 00:40:20 any newbies in RP will see it then Feb 08 00:40:26 I'm with Lun-Ur - advertising is probably our second-most important thing Feb 08 00:40:31 after building trust Feb 08 00:40:36 Yes ... I stated that wrong ... but the exact placement of the guildhouse will have much of an effect on advertising to newbies Feb 08 00:40:36 Agreed. Feb 08 00:41:12 My current plan is to hold a trade fair at the best game courts (Pharaoh's Playground?) as I want to create a huge all Egypt event Feb 08 00:41:12 Does anyone click on Guild Halls to read messages? Feb 08 00:41:12 Hrm. Feb 08 00:41:12 (actually, I do...) Feb 08 00:41:12 I did a little Feb 08 00:41:12 I did Feb 08 00:41:12 I did all the time .. but I was still quite new Feb 08 00:41:12 Thats good, Hiro Feb 08 00:41:12 I stopped fairly quickly Feb 08 00:41:21 sometimes Feb 08 00:41:26 we also need to get Teppy to put us on famous guilds Feb 08 00:41:30 --> Earwin (earwin@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:41:30 Guild messages are often read by those looking to start a guild Feb 08 00:41:43 I did, but most messages are not aimed at passers by Feb 08 00:41:47 Got booted :( Feb 08 00:41:54 Makes me think being in the "Famous Guilds" is importatnt, if not something even better placed... Feb 08 00:41:57 RP map: http://www.atitdmaps.com/maps/index.php?id=1&mode=1&sub_map=4 Feb 08 00:42:03 Then we need an attraction. A reason for people to come to the guild hall. Feb 08 00:42:09 Public facilites? Feb 08 00:42:15 Contests? Feb 08 00:42:15 Dancing girls? Feb 08 00:42:20 Who's going to be at the hall? I did all my trading via /chat Feb 08 00:42:36 public facilities would probably be the best bet Feb 08 00:42:39 The hall works as a) a meeting place and b) advertising Feb 08 00:42:40 Hellinar, did you sit at the Exchange all day? Feb 08 00:43:07 I don't mean for them to want to come to the guild hall specifically, just a reason for them to be around our advertising. Feb 08 00:43:13 But you'll probably want to meet fellow traders and customers at the wearhouse, where the goods are located. Feb 08 00:43:19 If you are in RP this weekend check out the area around 833, 4747 Feb 08 00:43:40 Right on the nile and at the cross roads from OE and VOK to RP Feb 08 00:43:51 I've seen that, Earwin, it looks nice Feb 08 00:43:58 The server is running this weekend? Feb 08 00:43:59 --> Pakotet (chludena@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:44:09 Hey. Feb 08 00:44:11 24 hours on saturday me thinks Feb 08 00:44:14 Planning on a 24h test tomorrow. Feb 08 00:44:21 that was the rumor teppy gave out Feb 08 00:44:27 Hi there Pakotet Feb 08 00:44:33 Hi Pakotet Feb 08 00:44:49 of course, his first rumor was 24h on thursday ... Feb 08 00:44:49 Lun, I did set at Mountain Market all day. But thats not a workable strategy in live for a single trader Feb 08 00:45:04 Did I miss much? Feb 08 00:45:33 --> Teppy[eGenesis] (teppy@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:45:38 Hiya Teppy. Feb 08 00:45:39 Pakotet: quite a bit, but it's all logged Feb 08 00:45:40 hi Teppy Feb 08 00:45:43 you have, but still a good deal going on :) Feb 08 00:45:47 Hey. Gonna lurk a bit. Feb 08 00:45:48 All hail mighty Pharaoh! Feb 08 00:45:51 cool. Feb 08 00:45:53 Hello Pharoah Feb 08 00:45:57 Helping the builders right now. Feb 08 00:46:01 * Hirokache kneels Feb 08 00:46:02 Well one natural for a Trade Guild is to evolve into a bazzar Feb 08 00:46:16 the trade fairs should do that in the early going Feb 08 00:46:16 Egypt on tomorrow Teppy? Feb 08 00:46:42 if we get critical mass then I agree, Earwin, we can make it a permanent bazaar Feb 08 00:46:47 Teppy, can we get the Egyptian time and date published on ataleinthedesert.com? it will help with organising events in Egypt time Feb 08 00:46:56 The Traders are the ones that should establish the trade fairs Feb 08 00:47:12 what have we accomplished so far? Feb 08 00:47:15 Earwin, stop with the crazy logic... Feb 08 00:47:17 guild hall location? Feb 08 00:47:31 Locaton: RP for sure Feb 08 00:47:34 Sorry I get carried away Feb 08 00:47:57 Agreed re: location Feb 08 00:48:00 ... summary ... one of two names, we start spread out and meet on Sunday Feb 08 00:48:00 We should build the hall when we can see a definate center of people living in RP. Feb 08 00:48:22 It takes about 5 to 8 people to establish a 24/7 presence, according the The Sims Online. (There whole game is based on establishing a 24/7 presence. Feb 08 00:48:25 Thanks Lun, I'm not very good with summaries :) Feb 08 00:48:48 The Guild Hall is probably in RP, but I hear from Teppy that there are now new regions! Feb 08 00:49:05 That's what it looks like from the new map, yeah. Feb 08 00:49:05 Wow, that changes things. Feb 08 00:49:08 Which is why I am more in favor of Trade Fairs at regular intervals Feb 08 00:49:13 Tomorrow I'll go online for a few hours of running to see what's new. Feb 08 00:49:14 and nrp is not a central location Feb 08 00:49:29 No matter how you cut it RP is close to the center of Egypt Feb 08 00:49:30 Where is the new map? Feb 08 00:49:33 I dunno, RP still seem middle of map. Feb 08 00:49:42 The builders are building right now. Feb 08 00:49:46 maybe srp Feb 08 00:49:49 do we have a new map? Feb 08 00:49:56 atitd.net, the real big png file Feb 08 00:49:56 yes Feb 08 00:50:04 oi Feb 08 00:50:12 NRP is a bit far north. The "impassible mountains" might be more central Feb 08 00:50:24 can we get a .jpg? Feb 08 00:50:31 all egypt map: http://www.atitdmaps.com/maps/index.php?id=1&mode=1&sub_map=0 Feb 08 00:50:35 but it has to be central with a population locus, right? Feb 08 00:50:44 Is that the updated map, or Beta3? Feb 08 00:50:57 just the tech tree one Feb 08 00:51:04 but it gives an idea Feb 08 00:51:16 No, it has to be central in order to optimize waypoint time. Most traders will be not be in RP. Feb 08 00:51:17 --> Renok (Renok@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:51:36 hi people ni dont know :) Feb 08 00:51:41 Hi Renok Feb 08 00:51:47 I believe the intended start points are VoK, Sinai and 7L Feb 08 00:51:49 Exactly, especially if we get Lun's store passed into law Feb 08 00:51:50 Hi Renok! You are new? Feb 08 00:51:56 Hello Renok Feb 08 00:51:58 to what? Feb 08 00:52:00 RP is central to them Feb 08 00:52:02 im new to beta Feb 08 00:52:26 or was it VoK, Sinai and OE.. :/ Feb 08 00:52:26 http://dragynne.freeservers.com/mapmod.html Feb 08 00:52:28 Welcome, although beta has ended Feb 08 00:52:33 im not actually in trade guild im just watching you :) Feb 08 00:52:35 bigger map Feb 08 00:52:48 Well I have been at 0,0 but which is a central as you can get, but pretty isolated :D Feb 08 00:53:01 Looking at map now... they terraformed two long rivers parallel and west of Nile. Feb 08 00:53:11 Please feel free Renok, and feel free to jump in with any thoughts as well :) Feb 08 00:53:17 yay Feb 08 00:53:27 Thanks obi, now this is a BIG MAP Feb 08 00:53:38 lol glad to help Feb 08 00:53:45 the geographical center is near the north of Seven Lakes Feb 08 00:54:01 RP is still central to VoK, OE, Sinai and 7L. Feb 08 00:54:45 establish the guild hall near liberty bridge early game, then we can make the storage area elsewhere Feb 08 00:55:03 --> AnthraX101 (Whee_@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 00:55:08 No, few people are going to live in the far south, unless the builders have outdone themselves Feb 08 00:55:17 we do need the guild hall near the elders Feb 08 00:55:35 im still not even entirely convinced im getting game..... Feb 08 00:55:40 good point - where are the elders likely to live? Feb 08 00:55:58 nrp... Feb 08 00:56:02 I think RP is good enough for a start Feb 08 00:56:12 I suggest we decide upon the location after at least seeing some of the new map. I'll be there tomorrow to look around, probably to run from 7L to OE and scout the terrain Feb 08 00:56:27 That's kind of the point Ren, its still a mystery Feb 08 00:56:46 The bridge may have been changed for all we know... Feb 08 00:57:00 This map looks updated Feb 08 00:57:05 Does anyone know if there will be starting points in E/W Grounds, down in the south? Feb 08 00:57:18 If not, then RP is still central to -inhabited- areas. Feb 08 00:57:23 It's based on population and Welcome Banners Feb 08 00:57:28 bridges are all the same Feb 08 00:57:35 I know at least one player who's going to live down in EG Feb 08 00:58:24 We need a potters wheel asap, two WP is so nice Feb 08 00:58:26 only new trees and schools and unis and some gaming areas Feb 08 00:58:27 I would expect there will be people living all across the mpa before too long Feb 08 00:58:56 No, we're traders! We need 50 jugs, not a pottery wheel. Feb 08 00:59:01 Yes, getting waypoints are certainly nice ... but I think that should be an individual focus Feb 08 00:59:07 :D Feb 08 00:59:16 Which ... well, Lun stole me words, Feb 08 00:59:19 Could start in RP. If population shifts later, we could relocate. Feb 08 00:59:32 actually, for the later Nav stuff, we should maybe cooperate Feb 08 00:59:37 I didn't build any pottery wheels. I did have access to 6. Yes, I did dig my own clay. Feb 08 00:59:44 trade with an eye for hoarding iron ore etc... Feb 08 01:00:03 Wow you dug clay I am impressed :D Feb 08 01:00:17 Right, that would make sense, especially for any solo members of the guild (as odd as that sounds) Feb 08 01:00:19 There are usually public Iron mines. Or you trade the owner of the mine your time for 200. E.g. you mine 400-500 and ask for 200. Feb 08 01:00:52 <-- DWing010[NRP] has quit (Quit: ) Feb 08 01:01:22 You can get anything you want for a trade. That's the whole point. You can get tuition, you can get buildings built for you, you can get taught lessons. Feb 08 01:01:36 I'm just saying that one of our goals might be to get more traders Feb 08 01:01:48 Quite true Lun :) Feb 08 01:01:57 and if we have Nav skill reqs in stock, it would be easy to help people along... Feb 08 01:02:00 and we will if this is sucessful Feb 08 01:02:12 Anything else on the subject? Feb 08 01:02:15 Yes, if there are profits, then you can get Nav stuff Feb 08 01:02:15 oops Feb 08 01:02:20 --> aukks (Aukks@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:02:24 nm, was lagging, thought people had stopped talking ;) Feb 08 01:02:24 Though we have to remember some trade guild members won't be full time traders and will look at other things to do as well. Feb 08 01:02:28 hello aukks Feb 08 01:02:36 Hi ho. Feb 08 01:02:37 Nav skills packages will be a good seller I think Feb 08 01:02:42 ... poll ... full time or part time trader? Feb 08 01:02:45 * Renok would join but doesnt like trading.... Feb 08 01:02:47 Do we want to sell services? Feb 08 01:02:57 part time Feb 08 01:02:58 Part time Feb 08 01:03:05 part time Feb 08 01:03:05 full time Feb 08 01:03:07 full time Feb 08 01:03:11 full-time in the sense that I'm always willing to carry something when I travel Feb 08 01:03:13 well, full time when playing part time Feb 08 01:03:19 lol Feb 08 01:03:26 Lun-Ur: agreed :) Feb 08 01:03:26 * Renok is very confuzzled Feb 08 01:03:44 Which is the confuzznig part Renok? :) Feb 08 01:03:50 Well, hmm, looks like I'm not needed here ;) Feb 08 01:03:56 Ahmeni: What services did you have in mind? Feb 08 01:03:57 <-- aukks (Aukks@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has left #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:04:01 I think you just decided upon the Elders of the guild. Hiro, Cheph, and perhaps Ahmeni Feb 08 01:04:09 We Need AukkS!!! Feb 08 01:04:14 Yes we do! Feb 08 01:04:26 And for services I was thinking of things like mechanics and lesson teaching Feb 08 01:04:30 Who is Aukks? Did we forget to say hi? Feb 08 01:04:36 I said Hi :) Feb 08 01:04:51 Dangit, he logged off Feb 08 01:05:19 Lun-Ur: aukks is elder of FoN Feb 08 01:05:20 brb Feb 08 01:05:28 Nearly everything is tradable. The only exceptions are camels, tests, and stats. Feb 08 01:05:34 <-- Renok (Renok@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has left #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:05:36 Missed last question: busy part time trader. Feb 08 01:05:48 He's not on #ATITD Feb 08 01:05:49 I do wish one could package food Feb 08 01:06:10 I really wish you could trade camels. Feb 08 01:06:10 17:05:39 ]  · · Quits: aukks Feb 08 01:06:28 I tried to buy alter locations to pass the Bedoin tests. Couldn't afford them :-( Feb 08 01:07:05 bound to be public info eventually.. Feb 08 01:07:15 How do you buy alter locations, of you mean the coordinates Feb 08 01:07:17 Please think out of the box. Yes, straw is tradable. So is the coordinates to the Red Sand. Feb 08 01:07:25 i will help you with that after i finish bedoin myself, lun-ur Feb 08 01:07:32 information economy, atitd version :) Feb 08 01:07:34 Does anyone intend to be a specialist trader? Metals, food, crystals, gems? Feb 08 01:07:39 Yes, I found out who just passed the Test of the Bedu and then tried to get the coords from him and his guildies Feb 08 01:08:01 Or a specialist merchant, glass, steel, tin, etc? Feb 08 01:08:06 Not I, I plan on trading whatever works Feb 08 01:08:08 I was thinking out of the box but then I traded the damn box away Feb 08 01:08:09 I plan to specialize in making people happy :) Feb 08 01:08:10 Hrm. You might consider it specialization.. I plan to hire myself out as labour. Feb 08 01:08:15 I'm interested in metals and finished goods. Feb 08 01:08:24 I found trading everything got a bit much as the techtree expanded Feb 08 01:08:30 --> Renok (Renok@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:08:35 I would trade sand for mud if asked Feb 08 01:08:40 laf Feb 08 01:08:49 hehe Feb 08 01:08:55 lol Feb 08 01:08:59 hehe ... I hope you would then give the newbie a lesson or two ;) Feb 08 01:09:07 lol Feb 08 01:09:10 It did get harder to fufill requests when more items appeared. Feb 08 01:09:15 i wouldnt trade anything unless i made a handsome profit Feb 08 01:09:19 or it was for noob Feb 08 01:09:25 But it made it interesting to have new things to trade. Feb 08 01:09:28 course im kinda a noob too : ) Feb 08 01:09:39 to what extent are you guys likely to pool things? Feb 08 01:09:41 Lun-Ur: that's when we'll leverage our strength in numbers, I think Feb 08 01:09:46 Not many people make things like pinch rollers or brass plates for trade. Could we charge an assembly fee? Feb 08 01:10:04 i'm sure we will be members of other guilds and each may have a special item that is best for them to trade and that's what this guild wil specialize in Feb 08 01:10:20 trades i mean Feb 08 01:10:36 Pinch rollers are a good reason to be a member of a builder's guild. You can use charge Iron + price and use your "own" forge to make the damn thing. Feb 08 01:10:39 homegrown is good at glass and metals Feb 08 01:10:39 In beta 2, one guild traded Automation kits Feb 08 01:10:57 yes obiwan ... whle I'm not limiting myself to any one thing, what my guild has and needs will effect my trading to a point Feb 08 01:10:58 In beta 3, Bada traded Automation kits too Feb 08 01:11:11 I sold a few mine automation kits Feb 08 01:11:20 that's true for all of the guils Feb 08 01:11:35 There are so many services that you could possibly offer, though Feb 08 01:11:36 It's very hard to find a buyer for one of those kits. It's very very hard to determine the price. Feb 08 01:11:38 I have limited play experience, but I did find that buying and selling time in the firing of a forge or casting was possible. Feb 08 01:11:42 Pinch rollers and up might have to wait till currency is common to be easy to trade Feb 08 01:12:02 Hellinar: agreed Feb 08 01:12:02 --> Sandy_ (pb2@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:12:03 Heck, you could even have a service where you paid someone to figure out how to use your glazier's bench. Feb 08 01:12:26 I almost sold a few pinch rollers in Beta3... It seems it's hardest to sell expensive items... Feb 08 01:12:29 Lun, those are the kind of things I would see being traded at a Trade Fair. Feb 08 01:12:37 Ahmeni: true. I hear they're changing the charcoal hearths. How much is an efficient method worth? Feb 08 01:12:53 At first quite a bit Feb 08 01:12:59 skip hearths and get ovens Feb 08 01:12:59 I think that information is likely to be a difficult commodity to trade Feb 08 01:13:01 I can't imagine who'd make 8 or 10 or 20 Pinch Rollers to go sell at the fair? That seems like a weeks worth of work. Feb 08 01:13:10 it'll be expensive to start with and rapidly become free Feb 08 01:13:15 Though as the info got around it would decrease to nothing Feb 08 01:13:36 as soon as someone like me or Meffi gets info, it's free ;) Feb 08 01:13:45 Actually, Cerealkil discovered the carrot secret first, and was trying to trade it for another veggie secret before the info went public. Feb 08 01:14:03 Hearths have pretty high volume now Feb 08 01:14:03 But most players make their knowledge public. Feb 08 01:14:08 hard to keep a lid on stuff when it's just a forum post away from being public Feb 08 01:14:11 Lun, depends on the market price, and if there is any benefit to producing 10 at a time rather than 1 Feb 08 01:14:25 afk one sec, phone Feb 08 01:14:25 Are we going to have a "standard" for pricing, like everyting valued in charcoal or wood or straw? Feb 08 01:14:38 or not Feb 08 01:14:42 u mean a common currency Feb 08 01:14:45 I think pinch rollers would be very valuable, and probably worth the time for whoever wanted to put the effort in Feb 08 01:14:45 pinchrollers are so expensive, if you have the resources to buy one, you could probably just build your own. Feb 08 01:14:45 No, it won't work without currency Feb 08 01:14:49 instead of bartering Feb 08 01:15:17 Although... rollers need a casting box, so how much above cost of materials is it worth to not have to build the casting box? Feb 08 01:15:26 I'm in favor of wood, but that might not be a good idea, as it's infinitely renewable... Feb 08 01:15:29 Master's forge for pinch rollers Feb 08 01:15:34 That's the flaw with things like mine automation kits. You have to trade something of equal value. Bada wanted like 500 ash. Bartering such quantities is difficult. Feb 08 01:15:37 We can figure out averages and the like and post thsoe for public knowledge, but any set standard before currency will be impossible Feb 08 01:15:39 Straw worked in Beta 2, but people could carry 1000. Wood seemed to be the most common coin in Beta 2 Feb 08 01:15:43 Beta 3 Feb 08 01:15:43 im new to game is there gold in heres? Feb 08 01:16:03 Backing currency woun't be easy Feb 08 01:16:05 Good low-tech example: rock saw. Expensive to make, what would you pay to just turn a med. stone into a flywheel? Feb 08 01:16:05 Actually, charcoal was the basis in 7L, wood everywher else Feb 08 01:16:07 There is but very rare Feb 08 01:16:10 Renok, those questions are best asked in #atitd. Feb 08 01:16:24 yah but im lazy and noone is awake there :) Feb 08 01:16:29 Pak, I made them for free if someone stopped by Feb 08 01:16:34 did straw devalue when greenhouses became available? Feb 08 01:16:43 Straw had no value in Beta3 Feb 08 01:16:50 I meant in b2 Feb 08 01:16:59 (if there were greenhouses..) Feb 08 01:17:18 Wood seems like a stable commodity since harvesting is well controlled Feb 08 01:17:35 Wood is good but why not flax? Feb 08 01:17:36 It's like leather. It has a lot of value until there are a lot of breeding sheep, then it has little value. Feb 08 01:17:59 Wood is not dense enought to make a good currency. 500 wood isn't really worth 1 canvas. Feb 08 01:18:04 Ya flax is a reasonable standard too Feb 08 01:18:06 it can be stable in one area perhaps ... but things will vary region to region, and still quite a bit person to person Feb 08 01:18:16 --> ankin (whome@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:18:16 maybe it'll evolve as the game evolves Feb 08 01:18:18 Hrm. I like the idea of flax. But rotten or fresh? Feb 08 01:18:19 Not with a Steel Ax or especially a Fine Steel Ax Feb 08 01:18:20 Nope, straw did not devalue, because all branches of the techtree advanced in step, roughly. Teppy keeps it that way Feb 08 01:18:27 Wood for the first 3 days Feb 08 01:18:31 then flax Feb 08 01:18:44 hi all Feb 08 01:18:48 HI ankin Feb 08 01:18:49 hi Feb 08 01:18:50 Hell ankin Feb 08 01:18:57 HellO that is Feb 08 01:18:57 Don't forget, we are dealing with a managed economy here. Teppy has powers the Communist apparatchicks only dreamed about Feb 08 01:19:06 lol Feb 08 01:19:07 True Feb 08 01:19:14 No, you miss the point. You can't have ONE standard commodity. Then both the 'buyer' and 'seller' will want to trade with you in that commodity. You then need inventory, etc. It's very hard to bootstrap Feb 08 01:19:20 yah if teppy cuts down on something its value skyrockets Feb 08 01:19:34 or vice versa Feb 08 01:19:38 This debate brings up a good poll... Feb 08 01:19:41 ... poll ... What style of trading will you use? Feb 08 01:19:53 Closed Order Book Feb 08 01:19:58 Auction Feb 08 01:20:00 none of the above : ) Feb 08 01:20:01 trying to match buyers/sellers Feb 08 01:20:05 Well I am suggesting if we set a standard then everything (common at least) can be translated. 1 flax = 2 wood, 10 straw = 1 wood, 1 charcoal = 10 wood etc. Feb 08 01:20:12 Lun-Ur I disagree, just because everything is correlated to one thing doesn't mean you can't figure out how two other things will trade for Feb 08 01:20:20 Earwin, that'll probably vary Feb 08 01:20:31 True Sandy Feb 08 01:20:33 but ... Feb 08 01:20:37 Sure and we track it Feb 08 01:20:44 if you have one thing as a base ... everyone will want as much of that one thing as possible Feb 08 01:20:53 Sure, but you have to track it to seconds. That's the only stable commodity Feb 08 01:20:54 <-- Renok (Renok@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has left #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:21:10 Lun: time really IS money Feb 08 01:21:12 Lun, Ebay worked by pricing everything in Straw, but people rarely bought for straw, they would just use it as a conversion unit Feb 08 01:21:13 Wood varies by at least a factor of 3 depending on the ax Feb 08 01:21:27 I like that concept if I am a runner Lun, travel takes lots of seconds Feb 08 01:21:50 Until crossbreeding is established, though, flax has a stable value. Feb 08 01:21:51 Well... how many seconds per wood? That's quite variable, no? Feb 08 01:21:54 Which leads to the major problem of holding an inventory ... worrying about the change in prices, etc and etc ... Feb 08 01:22:11 right, the risks of being a trader Feb 08 01:22:15 Flax varies by variety, number of jugs, and number of players cooperating to grow it. Feb 08 01:22:28 Lun, but prices are an average of the productivity of wood cutters. The average Egyptian has a 2.5 axe Feb 08 01:22:33 I took no risks. I had no inventory. Feb 08 01:22:35 but the opposite can happen too Feb 08 01:22:35 if 8 people are standing around 1 tree... Feb 08 01:22:45 The EgyptBay owner takes no risk either. Feb 08 01:22:52 Any given thing is likely to be easier for one person than another. That doesn't change the fact it has some sort of market vallue. Feb 08 01:23:08 Plus, if you are camping a stand of trees, a steel axe isn't much of a help, except to give you more time to chat Feb 08 01:23:14 I second Lun ... no inventory means trading without that particular risk Feb 08 01:23:16 No, wood doesn't increase by people, it's 1/N. Feb 08 01:23:26 --> Renok (Renok@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:24:01 ... poll ... is this going to be a one-system trading guild (federation) or many-systems (co-op)? Feb 08 01:24:08 As with rl capitalism it isn't what it's worth it's what people are willing to pay for it - though they are related Feb 08 01:24:11 co-op Feb 08 01:24:17 co-op Feb 08 01:24:20 im not in guild but i'd vote for coop Feb 08 01:24:24 as much as I would like it all run my way .... that just isn't feasible :) Feb 08 01:24:26 co-op Feb 08 01:24:27 My experience in Beta 2 was that a 25% margin more than covered inventory risk due to prices changes. Don't foreget, everyone doesn't instantly get a technology when it is dicovered Feb 08 01:24:29 change "it's worth" to "it costs" Feb 08 01:24:36 i like co-op, not "in" either Feb 08 01:24:48 the small regional guilds could have a tighter relationship Feb 08 01:24:55 co-op Feb 08 01:25:05 and we can change the relationship if we see the need Feb 08 01:25:08 Well what single commodity most drives the ecomony? As its availibily varys most everything else will follow )except rares again Feb 08 01:25:16 there can be other national trading guilds as well, if they are federations Feb 08 01:25:19 I mean, we don't necessarily have to declare that now Feb 08 01:25:26 co=op Feb 08 01:25:28 although I think a co-op would work best for the forseeable future Feb 08 01:26:14 If we agree this is a co-op, then we are just debating our trading methods for the sake of debate. We are all free to trade however we want. And thus the Guild doesn't really even need any wearhouses. Feb 08 01:26:29 Just a Guild Hall to host the chat channel. Feb 08 01:26:37 agreed Feb 08 01:26:52 yes Feb 08 01:27:13 We do need a "Wharehouse district", i.e. chests where we all store stuff at a common waypoint. For inter trader trading Feb 08 01:27:22 right Feb 08 01:27:25 around the guildhall? Feb 08 01:27:29 I agree Hellinar Feb 08 01:27:39 around the guildhall will work in the beginning Feb 08 01:27:42 it's good enough to start with Feb 08 01:27:44 Ah, yes, agreed Feb 08 01:27:47 We need some way for play A to leave something for player B to deliver Feb 08 01:28:00 That would be most convenient, but not necessary Feb 08 01:28:05 I think that might be up to the indicidual traders, Earwin Feb 08 01:28:13 Guild could build a few shared chests next to the guild hall. We would then all maintain our own chests nearby. Feb 08 01:28:15 sorry, in re; to ahving warehouse around the guildhall Feb 08 01:28:20 Yup gets back to the trust issue Feb 08 01:28:36 Pakotet: I agree Feb 08 01:28:45 So who gets the profits? Are we going to agree to trade amongst ourselves and aid in deliveries on a non-profit basis in order to increase trade across Egypt? Feb 08 01:29:00 Or does everyone who touches the trade share the profits? Feb 08 01:29:07 (if any) Feb 08 01:29:23 I am for your first statement Feb 08 01:29:24 Lun-Ur, I think a trader would have to cut his/her own deals Feb 08 01:29:27 profits: if we're trading each other what we need, hopefully we're both improving Feb 08 01:29:29 but I hope Feb 08 01:29:34 I think profits should go to those involved, with a % going to the guild. Feb 08 01:29:36 i'm not against delivery fees or making a small profit Feb 08 01:29:37 that we do it in a cooperative fashion Feb 08 01:29:49 Probably up to each trader. Feb 08 01:29:51 I don't know that we need to tithe to the guild or anything Feb 08 01:30:01 too hard to police, I would think Feb 08 01:30:12 If the Guild is just a Hall and chests, what's a tithe for? Feb 08 01:30:13 I would expect to work a deal with the other trader since both of us will prolly spend a bit of time Feb 08 01:30:15 No, certainly not to begin with. Feb 08 01:30:16 Does the guild need a percentage? What would it use it for? Research, public buildings, sure. Feb 08 01:30:17 the only guild fee I see being needed is a joining fee to expand the Hall Feb 08 01:30:36 and then we can take up collections Feb 08 01:30:36 * ankin can't stay but did want to register my interest in helping develop trade after release, thansk Feb 08 01:30:36 And perhaps if we ever create a Trade Guild currency ... Feb 08 01:30:39 Yes, all members should pay their own entrance fee. Feb 08 01:30:41 But I don't know that the guild wants to get involed in research, etc. Feb 08 01:30:41 on an adhoc basis Feb 08 01:30:50 for extra buildings, research, etc. Feb 08 01:30:52 Thanks ankin :) Feb 08 01:30:56 I think everyone should set their own rates. But if there was a public list of accepted rates one could compare against the list. One would have to decide about the trader and accuracy of the list based on speaking with others, boards, etc. Feb 08 01:30:59 <-- ankin has quit (Quit: Client Exiting) Feb 08 01:31:00 Well, if say we charge a fee to do deliveries and hooking people together, then part of that fee can go towards things that we fund (Events, Festivals, etc.) Feb 08 01:31:29 ... poll .. Is everyone having as much fun as me here? Feb 08 01:31:35 Most definately so ;) Feb 08 01:31:36 oh yeah, totally Feb 08 01:31:37 Yes Feb 08 01:31:39 Yup Feb 08 01:31:40 yeah Feb 08 01:31:47 * Hirokache its been an hour and a half already? Feb 08 01:31:52 Probably currency should be released by a separate organisation within the guild, the Trade Guild Bank Feb 08 01:31:56 :) Feb 08 01:31:59 * Chephren checks the atomic clock Feb 08 01:32:03 hehe Feb 08 01:32:03 guild buildings: guild hall, warehouse chests, mint. But we could always just pass the hat when those come up. Feb 08 01:32:09 well this is an eye opening experience Feb 08 01:32:24 I realy don't expect currency until May or June. I'm not worrying about it. Feb 08 01:32:25 Hellinar: yes, that makes sense ... would certainly fit in with the coop nature that we all seem to want much better Feb 08 01:32:38 One thing is for sure, in 3 months the guild be be something we dont expect now :D Feb 08 01:32:43 However, Teppy told me there may be IOUs added to the game!!! Feb 08 01:32:51 Poll on how long do you think it will be before we have minting (earthtime)? Feb 08 01:32:52 expect the unexpected, eh, earwin? Feb 08 01:32:55 I'm in big favor of pass-the-hat Feb 08 01:32:58 One month Feb 08 01:33:05 So everyone agrees the guild house will be in River Plains right? :) Feb 08 01:33:07 Not until gold is found, sadly Feb 08 01:33:16 less than a month Feb 08 01:33:20 Depends on how strongly people want it, but I would think at least a month. Feb 08 01:33:22 Sure, wherever is most convenient for the Elders. Feb 08 01:33:30 I think River Plains makes a lot of sense unless we get in tomorrow or whenever Feb 08 01:33:34 RP Feb 08 01:33:35 and find a very different map Feb 08 01:33:45 RP Feb 08 01:33:47 RP is good with me Feb 08 01:33:51 also on guild fees: the accounting would be a pain Feb 08 01:34:02 I could handle accounting. Feb 08 01:34:07 I doubt one month will get perception 7 except via Dinner with Pharaoh. We'll see if anyone lucks out on the Ancient Map and finds gold. Feb 08 01:34:10 So you all aren't talking about having a guild house in each region? Actually that sounds better. Feb 08 01:34:14 where can I go to get a rundown of guild fees? Feb 08 01:34:18 within RP: liberty bridge? south RP? Feb 08 01:34:28 it's clouded my brain whenever I've tried to figure it out Feb 08 01:34:35 no dinner get the map Feb 08 01:34:40 Sandy_: I think that will be up to the traders in each region Feb 08 01:34:42 I think we will have to let RP decide its central of living, THEN figure out where we'll build. Feb 08 01:34:42 maps Feb 08 01:34:46 Hey Ahmeni when ya went through that valley I mentioned did ya see my sculpture on the hill? :) Feb 08 01:34:50 The map is going to be a whole lot smaller in Live Feb 08 01:34:56 i think there's at least 3 of us in Sinai going to do a regional guild. Feb 08 01:35:00 I don't think so, Earwin :( Feb 08 01:35:02 a whole lot smaller? Feb 08 01:35:06 smaller I hope not. Feb 08 01:35:06 If I end up in VoK I will definitely be going for one there Feb 08 01:35:27 Yes, much smaller area per reward. Feb 08 01:35:28 As to guild fees, if we are only building a guild hall, the only decision is how big to start, how big each increase Feb 08 01:35:36 The fees are than automatic Feb 08 01:35:43 ok Feb 08 01:35:43 speaking of regional vs. national guilds... how long til we actually establish this thing? a RL day? a RL week? Feb 08 01:35:50 I do not know RP very well at all. Feb 08 01:35:53 Oh you mean more universities and schools? Feb 08 01:35:55 I thought an RL day was a good idea Feb 08 01:36:01 Sunday night, say 7PM EST? Feb 08 01:36:03 a guild is what, bricks and boards to start with? Feb 08 01:36:11 10-person guild = 50 bricks and 110 boards + scs Feb 08 01:36:13 * Hirokache never built one Feb 08 01:36:20 did some math earlier Feb 08 01:36:21 Bricks, boards, and one Small Constr Site which is/was 1 canvas + 4 rope. Feb 08 01:36:21 Lun-Ur, that sounds about right Feb 08 01:36:26 er, per person Feb 08 01:36:39 Ahh right ... and costs may change a bit ... Feb 08 01:36:53 I have about a 12 hour run planned as soon as game goes live but might make it back to RP in that time Feb 08 01:36:54 It's not a big deal if a few of us show up to build it. The others can donate their share for later upgrades. Feb 08 01:36:56 cheaper to build all at once or upgrade in large steps Feb 08 01:37:20 right, someone had a forumla posted on the cheapest method Feb 08 01:37:28 start with 12-person guild then? Feb 08 01:37:34 The more you build up front, the cheaper per seat. But any trader worth a damn can bring 400 bricks and 100 boards. Feb 08 01:38:11 Boards get easier once you have carpentry shops. Canvas easier once you have a hand loom. So procrastination is good Feb 08 01:38:17 based on a 12 person guild, 676 bricks and 1540 boards Feb 08 01:38:17 AFK one capachion time :) Feb 08 01:38:29 bricks without a brick machine....sorry just got lost there for a moment Feb 08 01:38:39 Oh I guess, but 100 boards isn't hard. Feb 08 01:38:45 Yes :) And I've made sure I have the 15th off from work so I should easily have enough time to obtain a bunch Feb 08 01:38:55 Yuck! bricks are easy. 1500 boards with stone tools is not! Feb 08 01:39:00 I'd do that in a heartbeat for a good trading situation. Feb 08 01:39:03 that's total, right Pakotet? Feb 08 01:39:03 lol Feb 08 01:39:16 yes, total Feb 08 01:39:33 56 brick, 128 board per (or so) Feb 08 01:39:36 cool Feb 08 01:39:39 remember research is slow now, so dont count in having a carpentry shop for the first 5-7 days Feb 08 01:39:47 ... names .. Is anyone changing their name on the 15th? Feb 08 01:39:48 plus someone who has a loom Feb 08 01:39:52 no Feb 08 01:40:03 these numbers per the atid.net calculator, assuming the math doesn't change Feb 08 01:40:08 I am. Feb 08 01:40:10 I'm not ... well, I was Valrast in Beta but otherwise I'm all Hirokache Feb 08 01:40:10 i might Feb 08 01:40:15 ValDrast Feb 08 01:40:35 It's just one canvas so the Student Loom with break, but you can trash it afterwards. Feb 08 01:40:38 In live I will be known as Setau, but I'll keep Ahmeni as my out-of-game name. Feb 08 01:40:57 how do you like the name Remi Feb 08 01:40:58 I'll be Pakotet for all things atitd Feb 08 01:42:24 I just wrote down all 14 names (I know my own, thanks). I suggest all the Elders do the same. Feb 08 01:42:28 Are there any other starting issues that we haven't discussed? Feb 08 01:42:50 I think we're set, except for the name Feb 08 01:42:54 Can we try that one more time? Feb 08 01:42:57 let's have another chat before live? Feb 08 01:42:58 Hehe, I think I have most of these names written down already Feb 08 01:43:02 Who were the elders, again? Feb 08 01:43:08 ... poll ... Traders of Egypt ... or ... The Traders Guild? Feb 08 01:43:26 The Traders Guild Feb 08 01:43:27 The Traders Guild (or The Trade Guild) Feb 08 01:43:28 gah.. i just read that as traitors Feb 08 01:43:29 Traders of Egypt Feb 08 01:43:35 The Traders Guild Feb 08 01:43:37 Traders of Egypt, I prefer. Feb 08 01:43:37 Traders of Egypt Feb 08 01:43:46 the trade must flow... Feb 08 01:43:47 ToE Feb 08 01:43:51 Traders of Egypt between the two Feb 08 01:43:53 lol Feb 08 01:44:02 I don't want to be a toe Feb 08 01:44:04 ;p Feb 08 01:44:13 No, the nickname needs to be "Traders" Feb 08 01:44:20 --> DiGuru (frank.rade@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has joined #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:44:21 Trade Federation? (ooh, droids) Feb 08 01:44:24 There's no rule on 3 letters Feb 08 01:44:30 Lun_Ur: totally agree Feb 08 01:44:40 It's 5 to 3, Traders of Egypt Feb 08 01:44:58 You're free to call your local guild "The Trade Guild of " Feb 08 01:44:59 a'ight, traders of egypt it is Feb 08 01:45:11 we shoudl still so the poll on the atitd site Feb 08 01:45:27 You're free to call it "I'm a thief" is you don't want to trade anymore ;-) Feb 08 01:45:36 I think we should just go with the vote here. Feb 08 01:45:40 me too Feb 08 01:45:43 Even if that means I lose :) Feb 08 01:45:54 awww Feb 08 01:46:13 Traders R US Feb 08 01:46:17 so should we schedule another chat this week? Feb 08 01:46:26 It's Friday! You mean next week? Feb 08 01:46:27 Trade-O-Rama Feb 08 01:46:32 Wallmart Egypt Feb 08 01:46:36 The Tradinators Feb 08 01:46:38 Walmart Feb 08 01:46:38 lol Feb 08 01:46:39 Don't trade on me. nevermind Feb 08 01:46:40 Ok folks, got to go, see you on the Atitd.net boards, then by the Nile Feb 08 01:46:42 right, over the next 8 days Feb 08 01:46:46 thanks Hellinar Feb 08 01:46:47 the byg E Feb 08 01:46:48 later, hellinar Feb 08 01:46:50 SEe you later hellinar, thanks :) Feb 08 01:46:55 bye Feb 08 01:46:56 bye Feb 08 01:46:58 A Trade In The Desert :D Feb 08 01:46:58 <-- Hellinar (tdtravel@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has left #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:47:04 I think we're set for the 15th. We can use the forums for other debates. Feb 08 01:47:06 I'm thinking no on the chat unless we come up with a new list of things that we need to hash out before live Feb 08 01:47:11 ok Feb 08 01:47:18 DiGuru, now that's a good name! Feb 08 01:47:20 who's tasked with getting a guild forum? Feb 08 01:47:28 I'll do that Feb 08 01:47:32 thanks all Feb 08 01:47:34 (sorry to get all project manager-y :-)) Feb 08 01:47:39 Hiro is the leader, I'm just pushy :-) Feb 08 01:47:44 Website stuff can probably wait until after launch Feb 08 01:47:49 agreed Feb 08 01:47:53 agreed. Feb 08 01:48:07 Not agreed Feb 08 01:48:07 well this was really great Feb 08 01:48:09 Hiro, you'd better not be a griefer after all this work :-) Feb 08 01:48:18 lol Feb 08 01:48:23 heh Feb 08 01:48:27 Hehehe ... just wait ... i'll be salvaging wood planes like mad the first week! ;p Feb 08 01:48:40 Boy is a traders guild isnt a griefer magnet what is? Feb 08 01:48:48 has someone got logs to post? Feb 08 01:48:50 And how! Feb 08 01:48:55 I think getting the website up and running and advertising quickly is a good idea Feb 08 01:48:55 http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~mgg/atitd/irc_logs/thetradeguild.xchatlog is a full copy atm Feb 08 01:49:01 see...i was so considerate. i distroyed my own wood plane Feb 08 01:49:17 how? I believe the law that allows them to be after a certain period of time will still be in effect Feb 08 01:49:32 Well, it was o Kemet anyway ... which I suppose doesn't mean anything :) Feb 08 01:49:41 No one really knows what laws will carry over Feb 08 01:49:42 I don't think they'll actually be a whole lot of trading on the 15th. Everyone's going to be in a mad rush to build themselves a camp like they are used to. Feb 08 01:50:02 Lun: definitely Feb 08 01:50:08 right, which is why it's a good idea to meet the RL day after Feb 08 01:50:31 I bet wood brings a good price first day Feb 08 01:50:37 If you want to start on a web site now, go ahead. I'm trying to work (RL work) this week so I can ease off the week of the 17th Feb 08 01:50:41 my priorities are 1)my guild's camp 2)Sinai trade guild 3)joining ToE Feb 08 01:51:02 Alright, I'll get to work on the site, but won't have it listed anywhere until we all agree it doesn't look too horrible :) Feb 08 01:51:15 Hiro, whatever you do will be a plus Feb 08 01:51:22 I prolly should find a guild that will put up with a wacko Feb 08 01:51:27 agreed Feb 08 01:51:29 And do we want to pitch in for a new domain? with a couple of bucks from all of us it wouldn't be a problem Feb 08 01:51:36 OK. Plan on being on the atitd.net news by the 19th or 20th. That should be good timing for business. Feb 08 01:51:54 Feb 08 01:52:10 Hirokache, talk to it[BES] and yhe traders guide and website *might* make it into the manual. Feb 08 01:52:13 Ask one of the fan sites for space first. More domains with atitd in them don't help. Feb 08 01:52:14 I can paypal money to whomever grabs the domain Feb 08 01:52:32 Will do DiGuru, thanks Feb 08 01:52:40 I have lots of space Feb 08 01:52:51 im backs Feb 08 01:52:55 Thanks everyone! I have to finish work now... Feb 08 01:52:56 Byte Feb 08 01:52:57 Bye Feb 08 01:53:00 later, lun Feb 08 01:53:01 bye Feb 08 01:53:02 Bye Lun-Ur Feb 08 01:53:03 See you Lun :) Feb 08 01:53:07 <-- Lun-Ur has quit (Quit: ) Feb 08 01:53:08 I should go too Feb 08 01:53:10 Later all Feb 08 01:53:13 thanks everyone Feb 08 01:53:14 I need a break from the machine for a bit myself :) Feb 08 01:53:15 great stuff Feb 08 01:53:20 I'll get started on working on the trading databases Feb 08 01:53:24 <-- Earwin (earwin@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has left #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:53:28 i'm done too, good work, good night all Feb 08 01:53:28 cool Ahmeni, thanks Feb 08 01:53:37 bye Feb 08 01:53:40 <-- Pakotet (chludena@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has left #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:53:48 Good night too. Feb 08 01:53:48 --- Hirokache is now known as Hirokache_Away Feb 08 01:53:58 <-- obiwan (homegrown@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has left #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:54:00 <-- Chephren has quit (Quit: ) Feb 08 01:54:04 <-- Sandy_ has quit (Quit: Leaving) Feb 08 01:54:47 Ahmeni: are you going to post a log? Feb 08 01:54:49 <-- Renok (Renok@host217-36-18-142.in-addr.btopenworld.com) has left #thetradeguild Feb 08 01:55:00 Erm.. After i do all the editing stuff Feb 08 01:55:06 ok Feb 08 01:55:17 It'll probably get posted tommorrow morning some time Feb 08 01:55:30 if anything's gone wrong, there's a full one at http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~mgg/atitd/irc_logs/thetradeguild.xchatlog